Bekhorot 20 – בכורות כ׳ | Daf Yomi with Rashi, Tosafot, the Rambam and halacha
What Bekhorot 20 teaches
- Ravina explains the Rabbis disregard majorities that depend on mating, leaving the pregnancy status of a bought goat in doubt.
- A murky uterine discharge indicates a prior fetus, exempting subsequent births from bechor if sufficient time elapsed before conception.
- Ten ma'aser-eligible kids can emerge in one year only if the mother's triplet daughters each give birth to triplets.
The sugyot
- The Gemara resolves why a goat bought after its first year remains in doubt: either Rabbi Yishmael follows Rabbi Meir, or the Rabbis reject action-dependent majorities.
- The Gemara examines whether the first birth from an animal bought from a gentile is a definite firstborn, debating if we suspect prior miscarriage.
- The Gemara defines when discharge or milk exempts offspring from bekhorah, analyzing pregnancy timeframes and whether halakha fears a minority.
- The Gemara examines whether a goat can produce ten ma'aser-eligible descendants in a single year, probing gestation limits and litter sizes.
Halachot from the daf
- Following a majority dependent on human or physical action
- Firstborn status of animal acquired from a gentile
- Exemption from firstborn status by discharge of fetus or placenta
- Firstborn status of animal bought from gentile bearing offspring in first year
- Whether milk production exempts an animal from firstborn status
- Presumption of prior birth when an animal nurses an offspring
- Levirate concern when a mother-in-law departed overseas while pregnant
- Exemption from firstborn status through expelling a murky discharge (tinuf)
- Combining mother and offspring born within one year for animal tithe
Gems from the Daf
- Iyun of the day: Majority Dependent on Human or External Action
- 3 to remember: Bekhorot 20: three things to remember
- Halachot: Signs of Prior Birth and Firstborn Status
- The Rambam’s view: The Rambam on Fetal Discharges and Lactation
- Tosafot: Majorities, Presumptions, and Firstborn Animals
- Machloket: Does an Action-Dependent Majority Resolve Bekhorah Doubts?
- Words to know: Bekhorot 20: words to know
- Masechet so far: The masechet so far, chapter by chapter
- Elsewhere in Shas: Bekhorot 20 elsewhere in Shas
Learn Bekhorot 20 sugya by sugya on Super Daf: the Gemara in Hebrew and English with Rashi, Tosafot, the Rishonim, the Rambam and the Shulchan Arukh woven in. Free.