Super Daf › Bekhorot 46 › Gems from the Daf
Masechet so far · Bekhorot 46 · בכורות מ״ו
The masechet so far, chapter by chapter
Masechet Bekhorot explores the laws governing the consecration, redemption, and physical fitness of firstborn animals and human firstborns. Having completed thorough treatments of animal sanctity and disqualifying bodily blemishes for both offerings and priests, the tractate now turns to the laws of human firstborn sons.
Chapter 1 – הלוקח עובר חמורו: Redemption of the Firstborn Donkey
This chapter details the obligation to redeem a male firstborn donkey by giving a sheep or goat to a priest. Ownership partnership with a gentile or status as a priest or Levite completely exempts the donkey from this sanctity. If an owner refuses to redeem the firstborn donkey, its neck must be broken.
- Partnership with a gentile or ownership by a priest or Levite exempts a donkey from firstborn sanctity.
- A firstborn donkey is redeemed by giving a lamb or kid of any gender to a priest.
- An unredeemed firstborn donkey must have its neck broken from behind and be buried.
Chapter 2 – הלוקח עובר פרתו: Firstborn Kosher Livestock and Doubtful Deliveries
Male firstborn kosher livestock possess intrinsic bodily sanctity and must be given to a priest without redemption. Any gentile ownership interest or financial lien exempts the offspring from firstborn sanctity. When twin births or caesarean deliveries obscure birth order, rabbinic rules resolve priestly claims.
- Priests and Levites are fully obligated in the firstborn sanctity of their kosher livestock.
- Gentile ownership in an animal or its fetus completely exempts the offspring from firstborn holiness.
- When twin male lambs emerge simultaneously, Rabbi Akiva awards the leaner animal to the priest.
- Offspring delivered by caesarean section and any siblings born after them are exempt from firstborn status.
Chapter 3 – הלוקח בהמה: Purchased Animals and Shearing Bans
Purchasing a female animal from a gentile requires checking age or uterine discharges to determine if she previously gave birth. The Torah strictly forbids shearing a firstborn animal or putting its fleece to personal use. Plucking small amounts of hair is permitted only to inspect a blemish or facilitate slaughter.
- A murky uterine discharge indicates a prior miscarriage, exempting subsequent births from firstborn status.
- A purchased animal seen nursing is legally presumed to have calved, exempting her future offspring.
- Plucking hair by hand to inspect a blemish or make room for the slaughtering knife is permitted.
Chapter 4 – עד כמה: Rearing Time, Inspections, and Judges' Compensation
Owners must raise firstborn sheep for thirty days and cattle for fifty days before delivering them to a priest. A firstborn may only be slaughtered outside the Temple if an expert confirms a permanent physical blemish. Judges and blemish inspectors may not accept compensation, except as reimbursement for lost labor time.
- Owners must tend firstborn small livestock for thirty days and cattle for fifty days before giving them away.
- Court-authorized expert judges are exempt from paying restitution for mistaken legal rulings.
- A blemish examiner may take fixed compensation only if paid equally regardless of the verdict.
Chapter 5 – כל פסולי המוקדשין: Selling Disqualified Sacrifices and Inflicted Blemishes
Redeemed sacrifices are sold in public markets to benefit the Temple, but blemished firstborns may only be sold privately at home. Intentionally inflicting a blemish on a firstborn offering is forbidden, and the animal cannot be slaughtered for that flaw. Shepherds and owners face specific credibility rules regarding accidental versus intentional injuries.
- Blemished firstborn meat must be sold privately at home by estimate rather than weighed in open markets.
- Slaughtering an intentionally blemished firstborn is forbidden unless a separate, natural blemish subsequently develops.
- Israelite shepherds are believed to testify that blemishes occurred accidentally, but self-interested priest-shepherds are not.
Chapter 6 – על אלו מומין: Permanent Physical Blemishes in Animals
This chapter defines the permanent, visible physical defects that permit slaughtering a firstborn animal outside the Temple. Disqualifying blemishes include splits or holes in ear cartilage, structural growths in the eye, and broken limbs. Flaws that are temporary, internal, or concealed do not permit non-sacrificial slaughter.
- Ear cartilage that is split, lacking, perforated by a bitter vetch, or dried out permits slaughter.
- An eye defect called tevallul disqualifies an animal when white tissue extends across into the pupil.
- Dislocated thighbones, missing or extra legs, and broken limb bones permit slaughtering a firstborn outside the Temple.
Chapter 7 – מומין אלו: Disqualifying Blemishes in Priests
All permanent and transient physical blemishes that disqualify animals also bar priests from performing the Temple service. Priests are additionally disqualified by human-specific anomalies such as abnormal head shapes, facial asymmetry, or mismatched limbs. A priest with a forbidden marriage or corpse impurity cannot serve until he takes a formal vow.
- All bodily defects that disqualify sacrificial offerings also disqualify priests from serving in the Temple.
- Priests are disqualified by abnormal skull shapes, missing eyebrows, sunken noses, and bowlegged limbs.
- A priest married to a forbidden woman cannot perform the Temple service until he vows to forgo spousal benefit.
Chapter 8 – יש בכור: Human Firstborn Status: Inheritance and Redemption
This chapter distinguishes between a firstborn son for inheritance rights and a firstborn for priestly redemption through pidyon haben, the redemption payment of five silver sela coins. A prior miscarriage of a formed fetus exempts subsequent births from maternal redemption. The emergence of the head or forehead from the womb legally establishes birth.
- A son can be a firstborn for paternal inheritance, maternal redemption, both, or neither.
- Miscarrying a formed fetus exempts subsequent male children from the obligation of redemption from a priest.
- The head emerging from the womb legally constitutes birth, exempting any subsequent twin from redemption.