Bekhorot 47 – בכורות מ״ז | Daf Yomi with Rashi, Tosafot, the Rambam and halacha
What Bekhorot 47 teaches
- Rabbi Yochanan holds prior children born in gentility disqualify later sons from inheriting a double portion.
- A disqualified chalal son must redeem himself if his priestly father died within thirty days of birth.
- The first tanna denies firstborn status for both inheritance and redemption to caesarean-born sons and their younger brothers.
The sugyot
- Rabbi Yochanan maintains that the forehead alone establishes firstborn status, because the Torah’s recognition requirement for inheritance is independent of facial identification.
- Rabbi Yochanan and Reish Lakish debate whether a convert's prior children disqualify a subsequent son from the firstborn inheritance, which the Gemara aligns with rabbinic consensus.
- The Gemara examines whether the exemption from redemption of the firstborn follows paternal lineage, maternal tribal status, or the mother's womb.
- The Gemara examines whether a חלל son of a כהן must redeem himself if his father died within thirty days, concluding he must.
- A doubtful firstborn receives no double portion, and mutual power of attorney fails unless the claimants were recognized before being intermingled.
- The Mishnah defines non-viable miscarriages that do not disrupt firstborn status, and debates the status of a caesarean birth and his successor.
- A caesarean child and his subsequent vaginally born brother are both excluded from inheritance and redemption because neither fulfills the full biblical criteria.
- Rabbi Shimon deems a Caesarean son firstborn for inheritance as a valid birth, and the naturally born second son firstborn for redemption.
Halachot from the daf
- Facial identification for permitting remarriage versus recognition of a firstborn
- Firstborn inheritance rights for a convert with children from gentile status
- Fulfillment of procreation for a convert who had children before converting
- Exemption from redemption for son of Levite or priest's daughter and Israelite
- Redemption of son of Levite or priest's daughter impregnated by a gentile
- Right of a disqualified Levite woman to eat first tithe
- Redemption of a חלל son whose priest father died
- Claiming firstborn inheritance via authorization when identity or birth order is doubtful
- Redemption of a son born after an unformed miscarriage
- Inheritance rights of a caesarean-born son and the subsequent son
- Redemption obligation of a caesarean-born son and the subsequent son
- Firstborn status of a son delivered by caesarean section
- Firstborn status of a son born naturally after a caesarean delivery
- Redemption and inheritance for a son born after a caesarean section
Gems from the Daf
- Iyun of the day: Biological Paternity vs Halakhic Lineage in Inheritance
- Daf prep: Before you learn Bekhorot 47
- 3 to remember: Bekhorot 47: three things to remember
- The Passuk: The First of His Vigor Across Conversion
- Halachot: Firstborn Rights, Lineage, and Redemption Obligations
- The Rambam’s view: Lineage, Conversion, and the Sanctity of the Firstborn
- Tosafot: Inheritance, Maternal Status, and Self-Redemption in Bekhorot
- Machloket: Does a Convert's First Jewish Son Inherit Double?
- Words to know: Bekhorot 47: words to know
- Masechet so far: The masechet so far, chapter by chapter
- Elsewhere in Shas: Bekhorot 47 elsewhere in Shas
Learn Bekhorot 47 sugya by sugya on Super Daf: the Gemara in Hebrew and English with Rashi, Tosafot, the Rishonim, the Rambam and the Shulchan Arukh woven in. Free.